Defining Market Boundaries

The crux of any strategy formulation effort is market definition:

The problem of identifying competitive product-market boundaries pervades all levels of marketing decisions. Such strategic issues as the basic definition of a business, the assessment of opportunities presented by gaps in the market, the reaction to threats posed by competitive actions, and the decisions on major resource allocations are strongly influenced by the breadth or narrowness of the definition of competitive boundaries. The importance of share of market for evaluating performance and for guiding territorial advertising, sales force, and other budget allocations and the growing number of antitrust prosecutions also call for defensible definitions of product-market boundaries.4

Defining the market is difficult, however, since market can be defined in many ways. Consider the cooking appliance business. Overall in 1997 about 18 million gas and electric ranges and microwave ovens were sold for household use. All these appliances serve the basic function of cooking, but their similarity ends there. They differ in many ways: (a) with reference to fuels—primarily gas versus electricity; (b) in cooking method—heat versus radiation; (c) with reference to type of cooking function—surface heating, baking, roasting, broiling, etc.; (d) in design—freestanding ranges, built-in countertop ranges, wall ovens, counter-top microwave ovens, combinations of microwave units, and conventional ranges, etc.; and (e) in price and product features.

These differences raise an important question: Should all household cooking appliances be considered a single market or do they represent several distinct markets? If they represent several distinct markets, how should these markets be defined? There are different possibilities for defining the market: (a) with reference to product characteristics; (b) in terms of private brand sales versus manufacturers' brand sales; (c) with reference to sales in specific regions; and (d) in terms of sales target, for example, sales to building contractors for installation in new houses versus replacement sales for existing homes.

Depending on the criteria adopted to define the market, the size of a market varies considerably. The strategic question of how the marketer of home cooking appliances should define the market is explored below.

Dimensions of Market Boundaries

Traditionally, market boundaries have been defined in terms of product/market space. Consider the following:

A market is sometimes defined as a group of firms producing identical or closely related products. . . . A preferable approach is to define the markets in terms of products. . . . [What is meant by] a close relationship among products? Goods and services may be closely related in the sense that they are regarded as substitutes by consumers, or they may be close in that the factors of production used in each are similar.5

Some identify a market with a generic class of products. One hears of the beer market, the cake mix market, or the cigarette market. According to others, product markets refer to individuals who have purchased a given class of products.

These two definitions of the market—the market as a class of closely related products versus the market as a class of people who purchase a certain kind of product—view it from one of two perspectives: who are the buyers and what are the products. In the first definition, buyers are implicitly assumed to be homogeneous in their behavior. The second definition suggests that the products and brands within a category are easily identified and interchangeable and that the problem is to search for market segments.

In recent years, it has been considered inadequate to perceive market definition as simply a choice of products for chosen markets. Instead, the product may be considered a physical manifestation of a particular technology to a particular customer function for a particular customer group. Market boundaries should then be determined by choices along these three dimensions.6

Technology. A particular customer function can be performed by different technologies. In other words, alternative technologies can be applied to satisfy a particular customer need. To illustrate, consider home cooking appliances again. In terms of fuel, the traditional alternative technologies have been gas and electricity. In recent years, a new form of technology, microwave radiation, has also been used. In another industry, alternative technologies may be based on the use of different materials. For example, containers may be made from metal, glass, or plastic. In defining market boundaries, a decision must be made whether the products of all relevant technologies or only those of a particular technology are to be included.

Customer Function. Products can be considered in terms of the functions they serve or in terms of the ways in which they are used. Some cooking appliances bake and roast, others fry and boil; some perform all these functions and perhaps more. Different functions provide varying customer benefits. In establishing market boundaries, customer benefits to be served should be spelled out.

Customer Group. A group refers to a homogeneous set of customers with similar needs and characteristics. The market for cooking appliances, for example, can be split into different groups: building contractors, individual households buying through retail stores, and so on. The retail stores segment can be further broken down into traditional appliance specialty stores, mass merchandisers, and so on.

Decisions about market boundaries should indicate which types of customers are to be served.

In addition to these three dimensions for determining market boundaries, Buzzell recommends a fourth—level of production/distribution.7 A business has the option of operating at one or more levels of the production/distribution process. For example, producers of raw materials (e.g., aluminum) or component products (e.g., semiconductors, motors, compressors) may limit their business to selling only to other producers, they may produce finished products themselves, or they may do both. Decisions about production/distribution levels have a direct impact on the market boundary definition. This point may be illustrated with reference to Texas Instruments:

The impact that a business unit's vertical integration strategy can have on competition in a market is dramatically illustrated by Texas Instruments' decision, in 1972, to enter the calculator business. At the time, it was a principal supplier of calculator components (integrated circuits) to the earlier entrants into the market, including the initial market leader, Bowmar Instruments. As most readers undoubtedly know, TI quickly took over a leadership position in calculators through a combination of "pricing down the experience curve" and aggressive promotion. For purposes of this discussion, the important point is one of a finished product. Some other component suppliers also entered the calculator business, while others continued to supply OEMs. In light of these varying strategies, is there a "calculator component market" and "calculator market," or do these constitute a single market?8

Exhibit 5-3 depicts the three dimensions of the market boundary definition from the viewpoint of the personal financial transactions industry. Market boundaries are defined in terms of customer groups, customer functions, and technologies. The fourth dimension, level of production/distribution, is not included in the diagram because it is not possible to show four dimensions in a single chart. The exhibit shows a matrix developed around customer groups on the vertical axis, customer functions on the right axis, and technologies on the left axis. Any three-dimensional cell in the matrix constitutes an elementary "building block" of market definition. An automatic teller machine (ATM) for cash withdrawals at a commercial bank is an example of such a cell.

Redefining Market Boundaries

As markets evolve, boundaries may need to be restated. Five sets of "environmental influences" affect product/market boundaries. These influences are technological change (displacement by a new technology); market-oriented product development (e.g., combining the features of several products into one multipurpose offering); price changes and supply constraints (which influence the perceived set of substitutes); social, legal, or government trends (which influence patterns of competition); and international trade competition (which changes geographic boundaries).9 For example, when management introduces a new product, markets an existing product to new customers, diversifies the business through acquisition, or liquidates a part of the business, the market undergoes a process of evolution. Redefinition of market boundaries may be based on any one or a combination of the three basic dimensions. The market may be extended

Was this article helpful?

+2 0
Business Brains

Business Brains

To Build Your Business It Is Crucial That You Have The Correct Info And Tools And Learn How To Build A Correct Business Plan! This is one area you must pay attention to… There are many areas of a business plan that you may not know about but need to know about. For instance... you may have no idea about an executive summary.

Get My Free Ebook


  • iggi
    Why defining market space is important?
    7 years ago
  • efisio padovesi
    What is market boudries an product choice?
    7 years ago
  • nicole
    How to define market boundary?
    7 years ago
  • rahel
    What is boundaries of marketing plan?
    7 years ago
  • tekle
    What are the productmarket boundaries?
    7 years ago
  • manuela faerber
    What is the boundary that constitute market?
    7 years ago
  • arabella
    What are "product market boundaries"?
    5 years ago
  • diane brady
    What does it mean for market boundaries to be defined ?
    4 years ago
  • Aman
    What are the concept of boundary stuf in marketing?
    4 years ago
  • katri
    Where is boundre market?
    4 years ago
  • ABBI
    How can substitute products be used to define market boundaries?
    4 years ago
  • posco
    What is market boundaries structure?
    4 years ago
  • Luisella Mazzi
    What market boundary concept?
    3 years ago
    How many market are dere in bondary?
    3 years ago
  • Ulla-Maj
    What is product market boundaries and structure?
    3 years ago
  • cameron
    What is meant the boundaries of a business?
    2 years ago
    What are market area boundary?
    2 years ago
    Why are productmarket boundaries important?
    2 years ago
  • myrtle
    How to determine what product market boundaries are?
    2 years ago
    2 years ago
  • arnor
    How to define the jewellery market boundaries?
    1 year ago
  • mary keeley
    What are the two boundaries needed to identify the market?
    1 year ago
  • Sky Grant
    What is the boundry of the supermarket industry?
    1 year ago
    What are brand boundaries marketing?
    1 year ago
  • bellisima
    How boundaries work when defining markets?
    1 year ago
  • LIAM
    What are the current boundaries of the marketing plan?
    12 months ago
  • efrem
    What is the boundary aggressive advertising?
    11 months ago
  • valentina
    What is meant by industry boundaries?
    11 months ago
  • caramella
    How to distinguise product market bounderies?
    8 months ago
  • eija
    Which of the following markets has the most restrictive geographic boundary?
    7 months ago
  • helena boyle
    What is maeket boundary?
    6 months ago
  • tammy
    What are the two perspectives that can be used to define industry boundaries?
    4 months ago
  • rhiannon
    What is a defined market boundary?
    2 months ago
  • georgina
    What is a boundery of an industry?
    1 month ago
  • Mewael
    How to define the market with respect to geographic and product boundaries?
    1 month ago

Post a comment